top of page

Maximise your rental income!

Hotel or Airbnb? Here’s How to Decide

Planning a trip and torn between a hotel and an Airbnb? You’re not alone! Both options come with their own perks, potential drawbacks, and best-fit situations. This article will break down the key differences, helping you decide based on what matters most — whether it’s budget, convenience, comfort, or overall vibe. Let’s dive into the pros, cons, and practical tips to help you choose the right stay for your trip.


Stylish decorated living room

Hotel vs. Airbnb: Know What You’re Signing Up For


Imagine you’re about to book a trip. You’ve narrowed it down to a cozy hotel with a hot tub and spa or a charming Airbnb that feels just like home. But here’s the kicker: hotels and Airbnbs are pretty different. Knowing the basics can save you some surprises later on.


>> Hotels come with familiar perks like 24/7 check-in, room service, and the comforting knowledge that there’s likely a front desk clerk just a call away — perfect for those moments when you realize you’ve forgotten your room key again. Hotels are the tried-and-true option, ideal if you want everything to go as planned.

>> Airbnbs, however, are the wild card. Ever wanted to stay in a treehouse or a converted shipping container? There’s an Airbnb for that. These spots have personality, offering everything from full kitchens (hello, midnight snacks!) to backyards with grills. But keep in mind, it’s not exactly "pick up the phone and order extra towels" — you might need to text your host for those.


UpperKey logo

Comparing the Price: What’s Cheaper, Hotel or Airbnb? (Spoiler: It Depends)


When it comes to travel, the price tag on your accommodation can vary widely, and choosing between a hotel and an Airbnb isn’t always straightforward. While both options can be budget-friendly or splurge-worthy, their cost structures differ in ways that might surprise you. Here’s a breakdown to help you decide what’s actually cheaper based on your travel needs:


  • Nightly Rates and Extra Fees: Airbnbs often have lower nightly rates, especially for longer stays or groups, but cleaning fees can make short stays pricey. Hotels may appear simpler, but watch out for added costs like “resort fees” and parking, which can raise the overall price.


  • Discounts for Extended Stays: For week-long or longer stays, Airbnb usually wins, with many hosts offering discounts that make it ideal for extended vacations. Hotels may also offer discounts for longer bookings, but these are less common.


  • Best for Groups or Families: Airbnbs provide more space and flexibility for groups, often at a lower cost than booking multiple hotel rooms. This setup is also convenient for those who want kitchen access and communal areas, which hotels typically can’t match.


In the end, if it’s a short, solo stay, a hotel might be simpler. For longer trips, larger groups, or if you’re looking for a more home-like feel, Airbnb can be the more affordable and flexible choice.


Amenities and Convenience


When it comes to amenities, it’s all about the vibe you’re after. Do you want breakfast in bed, or would you rather brew your own coffee in a cozy kitchen? Here’s how hotels and Airbnbs stack up for different kinds of travelers.


>> Hotels are ideal for those who crave convenience. Think pools, gyms, spas, and room service — all ready for you at the push of a button. If your idea of a getaway includes lounging by the pool and ordering room service just because you can, hotels have you covered. Plus, that little “pretend you’re a VIP” feeling? It’s part of the experience.


>> Airbnb is perfect for travelers who want a "home away from home" feel. Here, you can whip up breakfast in your own kitchen, relax in a real living room, and explore neighborhoods outside the typical tourist spots. It might not come with a daily cleaning service or chocolates on your pillow, but it offers privacy, flexibility, and a sense of living like a local.


Breakfast in bed

Location, Location, Location


When it comes to where you’ll stay, it’s not just about the address; it’s about the experience.


>> Hotels are typically located right in the heart of the action. Need a quick cab to make it to a meeting? You’re in a prime spot. Want to be within walking distance of the landmark everyone’s sharing on Instagram? A hotel might be the ideal choice.


>> Airbnbs can vary widely in location. You might find yourself in a peaceful, charming residential neighborhood — or discover that "15 minutes to downtown" assumes a speed of travel you may not have access to. For travelers who enjoy uncovering unique, off-the-beaten-path spots, however, Airbnb can offer the perfect blend of adventure and discovery.


Experience and Ambiance


Some trips are about seeing the sights, while others are all about the experience. So, which is better — Airbnb or hotel?


>> Hotels offer a taste of luxury with a side of predictability. If you’re someone who finds peace in knowing your room will look just like the photos, hotels have you covered. There’s something reassuring about those fresh towels, spotless rooms, and a friendly front desk waiting to help — no surprises here!


>> Airbnb, though, can be a little more adventurous. From cozy cottages to chic city lofts, Airbnb stays are often one-of-a-kind. You might find yourself in a place decorated with quirky touches you’d never spot in a hotel — think of it as living like a local, complete with all the charm and personality that come with it.


Cozy living room

Safety and Reliability: Airbnb vs Hotel


Nobody wants to worry about safety on vacation, and here’s where the difference between hotels and Airbnbs can stand out.


>> Hotels offer the comfort of professional security, with features like CCTV, keycard access, and a 24/7 front desk. For solo travelers or those new to the area, this can add an extra layer of peace of mind.


>> Airbnbs, on the other hand, can vary in terms of security. Some provide excellent safety features, while others may feel less secure, especially if they’re located in residential buildings with shared access. However, Airbnb’s robust review system can be a great guide—just take a few minutes to check those ratings and reviews before you book.


When to Choose Each Option: Hotel vs. Airbnb


When to Choose Each Option: Hotel vs. Airbnb

Final Thoughts: Which Is Right for You — Hotel or Airbnb?


Choosing between a hotel and an Airbnb can set the tone for your entire trip. If you’re looking for convenience, consistent service, and amenities like breakfast and daily housekeeping, a hotel is your best choice. However, if you want more space, a local vibe, and a unique experience, Airbnb offers flexibility and a chance to feel like part of the neighborhood.


But whatever you choose, remember that travel is about the experience, not just the place you sleep. So book that trip, embrace the adventure, and make memories that’ll last a lifetime!


Calculate rental revenue


Determine your property's rental value with UpperKey as your tenant

bottom of page